Moss species

Conditions

Options

CO2 treatment

CO2 effect

N+ treatment

N+ effect

WTD

DWT effect

Duration

Remarks

Author(s)

Sphagnum fallax and Polytrichum strictum

Field

1) Uncut plants and 2) cut plants

360/560 ppm

1) Uncut: −HG, 0 LG, 0 MG (Sphagnum); −HG, −LG, −MG (Polytrichum); 2) Cut: −HG, 0 LG, 0 MG (Sphagnum); 0 HG, 0 LG, 0MG (Polytrichum)

0/3 g∙N∙m−2∙yr−1

1) Uncut: 0 HG, 0 LG, 0 MG (Sphagnum); 0 HG, 0 LG, 0 MG (Polytrichum); 2) Cut: −HG, LG = n.d., MG = n.d. (Sphagnum); −HG, −LG, 0MG (Polytrichum)

272 - 290 mm

Included into the models

245 days

The two treatment effects were tested on the three growth responses of both species with uncut and cut options. The aim is to test the validity and growth responses under specific treatments using different methods.

Present work

Sphagnum fuscum

Field

Uncut plants

n.d.

n.d.

Higher emissions in N and S but no significant differences measured the immissions

0 HG, 0 MG, 0 NPP

Varying between 0.5 m and 1m

Included into the models

4 years

The biomass is calculated from height increment using “cranked wires” and the specific bulk density for Sphagnum fuscum.

Wieder et al. 2010

Sphagnum fuscum, Sphagnum balticum, Sphagnum magellanicum and Sphagnum cuspidatum

Greenhouse

Uncut plants, although taken out of their environment (5 m depth)

n.d.

n.d.

0/4 g∙N∙m−2∙yr−1

Together with elevated temperatures (+4.2˚C): −HG, −MG, −NPP

Artificially maintained at −1 cm

Included into the models

2 growing seasons

The biomass is calculated from height increment using “Cranked wires” and the average (non-specific) bulk density.

Breeuwer et al. 2009

Sphagnum sp. & S. subnitens

Field

Uncut plants

Ambient/ ambient +235 ppm

−Cover (39%) but +total biomass (115%)

n.d.

n.d.

3 cm in control, 5 cm in eCO2

Not included in the model

3 years

Shift in plant community from Sphagnum spp. to vascular species, through a decline in S. subnitens cover (39%) and an increase  in J. effusus cover (40%), and 115% total biomass increase.

Fenner et al. 2007

Sphagnum palustre, S. recurvum and Polytrichum commune

Field and greenhouse

Cut plants (greenhouse), HG (cranked wire technique), Abundance and extrapolated MG (point-quadrat)

Ambient/ ambient +200 ppm

+HG (<1 year) and −HG (≥1 year) (Sphagnum, greenhouse); −MG (Sphagnum recurvum, field); 0 MG (Polytrichum, field)

n.d.

n.d.

18 - 23 cm (field); 4 cm (greehouse)

−MG (Sphagnum); 0MG (Polytrichum)

3 years

Greenhouse: Sphagnum growth was stimulated by elevated CO2 in the short term, longer term (≥1 year) growth was probably inhibited by low water tables and/or downregulation of photosynthesis. In the field only réduction of abundance for S. recurvum.

Toet et al. 2006

Sphagnum sp.

Field

Uncut plants. Cranked wire for HG, bulk densities of sections, point-quadrat for cover and NPP

n.d.

n.d.

N(40 kg∙ha−1∙y−1) and/or P (3 kg∙ha−1∙y−1)

−HG, −MG, −NPP

n.d.

n.d.

4 years

N addition depressed Sphagnum HG at four sites and reduced Sphagnum and NPP at two sites. P alleviates the negative impact N has on Sphagnum.

Limpens et al. 2004

Spahgnum recurvum

Greenhouse

Cut plants

700/420 ppm

+MG

n.d.

n.d.

n.d.

n.d.

n.d.

Capitula dry weight per pot for Sphagnum.

Hoorens et al. 2003